America's Christmas cookie cravings in 2025 lean heavily toward nostalgia, with classic recipes topping search trends across the country. Peanut butter blossoms emerge as the most popular cookie nationwide, especially across the West, Midwest, and Northeast. Peanut butter balls, or buckeyes, dominate the Southeast and parts of the Southwest and New England, while spritz cookies are favored most in the Northwest and scattered states elsewhere. Searches also reveal strong regional preferences for festive cookie shapes like stars, Christmas trees, snowflakes, and candy canes—proving that timeless traditions still rule holiday baking.