New York City is facing increased scrutiny regarding its response to a recent severe cold snap that has tragically resulted in 18 deaths, with 15 of these fatalities suspected to be hypothermia-related. The crisis has prompted an emergency City Council hearing where city officials admitted that the rapid and drastic drop in temperature took many residents by surprise. A central point of contention is the city's existing policy, which permits mentally fit homeless individuals to make their own decisions about seeking shelter during extreme weather conditions. This policy has sparked considerable debate and raised significant concerns about the ethical and humane treatment of those experiencing homelessness in New York City.